Ask Ian

Straight answers to consulting recruiting, case interview, and career questions.

Have a question for Ian?

Question submission is included with any Custom Case Coach course or coaching purchase.

Selected questions may be answered and added to the public Ask Ian library. Question submission does not guarantee a personal response or publication.

Browse questions

Clear filters

All

Case Interviews

Applications & Resumes

Recruiting Strategy

Networking

McKinsey

BCG

Bain

Online Assessments

Experienced Hire

Career Advice

Case Interviews

Most candidates benefit from enough practice to become consistent, not from chasing a fixed number. Focus on quality, review, and covering a range of case types.

Frameworks & Structuring

Start with profit equals revenue minus costs, then tailor each branch to the business. The best structure is specific enough to guide analysis without becoming a memorized checklist.

Case Math

Build reliable written steps before trying to calculate faster. Daily drills help, but most gains come from clearer setup, sensible rounding, and checking whether the result makes business sense.

Recruiting Strategy

Preparation and application timing should be planned together. Do not wait for perfection, but make sure you understand the recruiting calendar and can reach interview readiness before interviews are likely to begin.

Applications & Resumes

Consulting resumes are about evidence of impact, leadership, problem solving, and achievement—not prior consulting job titles. Translate your strongest experiences into concise, quantified bullets.

Networking

Ask focused questions that draw on the person's actual experience and help you understand the firm, office, or role. Avoid questions that can be answered from the firm's website.

McKinsey

The McKinsey Personal Experience Interview goes deeper on a small number of stories. Expect detailed follow-up questions about your actions, thinking, interactions, and results.

BCG Casey

Practice structured case thinking in a timed digital format. You still need sound business judgment, clear math, and careful reading even though the interaction differs from a live interview.

Experienced Hire

Not necessarily. Experienced-hire recruiting is more selective and role-specific, but relevant expertise, strong impact, and a clear reason for the move can create a credible path.