Firm Interview Guides

5 min read

7 Common BCG Casey Mistakes (and How to Fix Them)

7 Common BCG Casey Mistakes (and How to Fix Them)

7 Common BCG Casey Mistakes (and How to Fix Them)

Avoid seven common BCG Casey Chatbot mistakes involving time management, calculations, data interpretation, case structuring and final recommendations.

Avoid seven common BCG Casey Chatbot mistakes involving time management, calculations, data interpretation, case structuring and final recommendations.

Avoid seven common BCG Casey Chatbot mistakes involving time management, calculations, data interpretation, case structuring and final recommendations.

I get a lot of questions from candidates about the BCG Casey Chatbot.

How difficult is it? What questions should they expect? What happens if they make a mistake?

Here's what I'd focus on.

Casey tests many of the same underlying skills as a traditional case interview. But because you're working through a digital assessment under time pressure, certain mistakes become particularly costly.

These are seven I'd watch out for.

If you're not familiar with the assessment yet, start with my BCG Online Case guide.

Common BCG Casey Chatbot mistakes

Mistake #1: Trying to predict the exact test

Candidates love trying to predict the exact case they'll receive.

Will it be profitability? Market entry? M&A? Operations?

Who knows!

It's fine to understand the format, but stop trying to reverse-engineer the exact questions.

You need to know how to handle different business problems.

The fix: Practice a variety of cases and focus on the underlying skills.

Be ready for anything.

Mistake #2: Not reading the question carefully

This sounds obvious, but it's incredibly important.

Imagine you're looking at a table containing revenue, costs, customer numbers, and market shares.

You're asked which business unit contributed the most to revenue growth.

If you immediately start calculating profit, you're wasting time.

Even worse, you might end up selecting an answer that's correct mathematically but doesn't answer the question.

Pay attention to the wording, units, and instructions.

The fix: Before doing anything, make sure you know exactly what you're being asked to find.

Mistake #3: Mixing up the numbers

Here's a simple example.

A company's operating margin falls from 20% to 15%.

What's the decline?

It's 5 percentage points, or a 25% relative decline.

Those aren't the same thing!

Similarly, make sure you're distinguishing between revenue and profit, thousands and millions, percentages and absolute values.

I've seen this cause problems in traditional case interviews as well.

The fix: Write down what you're solving for, keep track of units, and sense-check your answer.

If you'd like to practice this with a business problem, try my worked BCG Casey practice questions.

Mistake #4: Spending far too long on one question

You don't have unlimited time.

You might know exactly how to solve a question but spend several minutes trying to make absolutely sure you're correct.

Meanwhile, the clock is ticking.

I'm not telling you to rush through questions or guess randomly.

But you need to get comfortable making decisions efficiently.

The fix: Practice under time pressure. Identify which types of questions slow you down and work on getting faster at those skills.

Mistake #5: Relying on memorized frameworks

This one is a classic.

Candidates memorize profitability, growth, market entry, M&A, and every other framework they can find.

Then they encounter a slightly unusual problem and don't know what to do.

Remember, a framework is a tool.

It's not the objective.

If your client is trying to improve profitability, understand the actual drivers of profitability.

If they're considering entering a new market, figure out what would make that investment attractive or unattractive.

Think about the business!

The fix: Practice creating structures from scratch rather than reproducing memorized ones.

Mistake #6: Describing the chart instead of interpreting it

Let's say a chart shows that revenue increased by 15%, while costs increased by 25%.

What can you conclude?

You could simply repeat those two numbers.

But that's not particularly useful, is it?

The more important observation is that costs are increasing faster than revenue, putting pressure on profitability.

Now ask yourself why that might be happening and what the business should investigate.

That's where business judgment comes in.

The fix: Every time you review a chart, ask yourself, "So what?"

Mistake #7: Forgetting to make a recommendation

You spend the entire case calculating numbers, reviewing exhibits, and evaluating options.

Then you get to the end.

What should the client do?

You should be able to answer that!

Keep track of the important findings throughout the case.

If you've identified the main problem, the strongest supporting evidence, and the most attractive option, the final recommendation should be much easier.

The fix: Practice summarizing your recommendation in a few clear sentences, supported by evidence.

Don't just repeat everything you've analyzed.

If your assessment includes a video, my 60-second Casey video recommendation example shows how I'd do this.

How to stop making the same mistakes

After every BCG Casey practice test, I'd review the questions you struggled with.

Try to identify which of these areas caused the problem:

  • Knowledge: You didn't understand the business concept.

  • Comprehension: You misunderstood the question or exhibit.

  • Math: You made a calculation or unit error.

  • Time: You couldn't complete the question quickly enough.

  • Business judgment: You struggled to interpret the results or make a recommendation.

Then work on the specific weakness.

If you're already good at calculations but consistently miss important details in charts, why would you spend another ten hours on arithmetic?

Focus on what actually needs improving.

You can try my free BCG Casey demo to get started, or use the full BCG Casey simulator for timed practice and question-by-question review.

But don't just keep accumulating practice tests.

Learn from each one!